A Review of Dr. Sugarbaker's Results Using Tri-Modal Therapy on 183 Patients from 1980 to 1997

Get Help Today

Looking for help or additional information? Contact us today.
First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Phone:
Zip Code:
Comments:
Please enter the number below:
8130
February 15, 2007
The following abstract is from an article authored by Dr. David Sugarbaker of the Brigham and Womens Hospital in Boston. It is noteworthy that the patients with epithelial tumors generally have a significantly longer mean survival than the patients with mixed type/sarcomatous tumor.

Resection Margins, N2 status and Cell type Determine Survival in Trimodality Therapy of Malignant Pleural Mesothelioma (MPM):
 
Results in 183 Patients

Objectives: We review our experience with extrapleural pneumonectomy (EPP) in the multimodality management of MPM.

Methods: From 1980 to 1997, 183 consecutive patients underwent trimodality therapy involving EPP followed by adjuvant chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Standardized systematic pathologic analysis was undertaken.
 
Results: The cohort included 43 women and 140 men with a mean age of 57 years (range 31-76) and a median follow-up interval of 13 months. Overall survival was 36% at 2 yrs and 14% at 5 yrs (median 17 mo.). There were seven perioperative deaths (3.8% mortality). Factors affecting long-term survival were evaluated in 176 patients surviving surgery (among these, survival was 38% at 2 yrs and 15% at 5 yrs; median 19 mo.). As indicated in the table below, lack of N2 nodal involvement, negative resection margins and epithelial histology were associated with improved survival. Factorial grouping by N2 status and resection margins significantly stratified survival among all patients surviving surgery (p<0.02), and among those with epithelial histology (p<.02). Thirty-one patients with epithelial tumors, negative resection margins and without N2 involvement had a 51 mo. median survival (68% 2-yr, 46% 5-yr). A clinico-pathologic staging system previously published stratified survival (p<0.05; see table).
 
 

Variable

N

2-Year

5-Year

Median(months)

P Value

Epithelial

103

52%

21%

26

0.0001

Mixed/Sarcom

73

16%

0%

13

 

Margins(+)

110

33%

9%

15

0.02

Margins(-)

66

44%

25%

23

 

N2(+)

40

23%

0%

14

0.004

N2(-)

136

42%

17%

21

 

Epithel.N2(+)

21

38%

0%

20

0.052

Epithel.N2(-)

82

56%

24%

34

 

Epithel.N2(+) Marg(+)

12

29%

0%

14

0.013

Epithel.N2(+) Marg(-)

9

43%

0%

22

 

Epithel.N2(-) Marg(+)

51

49%

14%

22

 

Epithel.N2(-) Marg(-)

31

68%

46%

51

 

StageI

66

53%

20%

25

0.048

StageII

41

44%

14%

20

 

StageIII

69

17%

14%

16

 

 
These data support the following conclusions:
  • Multimodality therapy including EPP is feasible in selected patients with MPM,
  • Microscopic resection margins affect long-term survival, pointing to the need for further investigation of local-regional control strategies,
  • Mediastinoscopy to evaluate N2 nodes is recommended, and
  • Patients with epithelial, margin-negative, N2-negative resection enjoy long-term survival.
 
Mesothelioma Doctors Mesothelioma Support Groups Mesothelioma Clinical Trials